Beneath the Surface - Panufnik centenary: Symphony no.5 (Sinfonia di Sfere)

Introduction

Panufnik's symphonic output now has an explicit preoccupation with geometry – and for the Sinfonia di sfere of 1975 the composer drew a figure of the overall design, reproduced with thanks to his publisher Boosey & Hawkes:

If that looks remarkably complex, Panufnik offers a written explanation in addition. 'The title has no connection,' he says, 'with the philosophy of Pythagoras ("music of the spheres"), nor with astrology (unlike the planets which inspired Gustav Holst)' Instead, Sinfonia di sfere uses spheres of 'contemplative thoughts and emotions', or spheres that act as a framework 'enclosing meticulously organised musical material'. This was to become a preoccupation in further symphonic works, the need for a higher form of structure and organisation – and in this case, the hope that 'the listener might perhaps experience a kind of ascent into spheres of contemplative thoughts and feelings'.

Verdict

It is helpful to follow the diagram when listening to the Sinfonia di sfere, as I found it a more difficult work to listen to without it. For this is probably Panufnik's most experimental symphony, despite its seemingly rigorous structural control.

It is by some distance his most percussive, for the 'orchestral sphere' allows for 12 untuned drums to the orchestra, four to each player. In addition it contains solo roles for trumpet, horn, trombone and tuba. The percussive element is an eye-opener, because the massive rolling drums dominate the second, fifth and last of the nine sections. This in turn inspires the strings to drive forward purposefully, and the music has great momentum here.

Yet when the tempo subsides the mood is quite acerbic, as it is at the start, reprising some of the more awkward and fractious moments of the Sinfonia Sacra. This leads to a longer trombone solo that has quite a mournful tone. The third section is downbeat too, with the tuba to the fore.

In all truth this is the symphony I have struggled with the most so far, not on account of its form but its relative lack of motifs and melodies that are easy for the listener to cling on to. The Sinfonia di sfere is exciting for sure, but ultimately less satisfying.

Recordings and Spotify link

My references for the Sinfonia di sfere were two recordings - the Tampere Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by John Storgårds on the Ondine label, and the Polish Radio Symphony Orchestra under Lukasz Borowicz, part of the new CPO series. Both are excellent, though the Ondine version shades it just for the excellent recorded sound.

Next up: Sinfonia mistica