Dvořák string quintets from Berlin

The grainy sound of the double bass makes for a briefly mysterious start to Dvořák’s Op.77 String Quintet. This is a form that the composer mastered, the first to do so since Mendelssohn, and his first mature work in the form predates that of Brahms by seven years. Not only that, but Dvořák was able to work the possibilities of using five stringed instruments, using the conventional instrumenatation of two violins, two violas and cello in his first published work, the A minor quartet Op.1, and also in his later Op.97 work, shot through as it is with old American-inspired melodies.

Op.77, however, is more radical for its inclusion of a double bass, and this new recording from Berlin does it proud. It has all the attributes a successful Dvořák interpretation should have – vibrant rhythms, feeling but not too much sentiment in the slow movement, and a rugged texture in the first movement in particular, with the extra weight offered by the bass section fully exploited. It also inflects Dvořák’s melodies with authentic charm and resoluteness, meaning the performance carries some real substance.

As with much of this composer’s output, the melodies are the strong point, a facet the Berliners never fail to bring home. The motif of two chords that determines the music’s direction in the first movement is well played on each occurrence, the key to each of the sections that follow, while there are some beautiful moments of duet playing between the violinists Thomas Timm and Romano Tommasini. There is a nice heft to the chords in the Scherzo, too, though this is in part checked by a heavy pull on the breaks before the trio, which itself feels a bit slow to start with.

The accompanying pieces include the Nocturne, more often heard for string orchestra. Here it has a lovely weight and poise, not too much on the schmaltz but still beautifully romantic, with softly murmuring inner parts. It is well caught by the engineers, too – close but not too personal.

The only regret is that the quintet miss an opportunity to include Dvořák’s other masterpiece in the form, the Op.97 Quintet in E flat major. Instead we get the Scherzo which makes for a nice complement on the back of the Nocturne in the same key, but feels like short change indeed when the disc ends at just over 45 minutes. There would have been plenty of room to include the full work, despite its different instrumentation – but here the Scherzo is rather pointlessly arranged for the quintet with the bass. Well performed as it is, it feels like a loose end.

Hopefully the Berlin Philharmonic Quintet will redress this balance with a disc of that work and the Op.1 – both of which provide illustrations of an aptitude for string writing that served Dvořák well throughout his compositional career. All the quintets deserve more air time – so this new recording helps that cause!

All about chemistry - Borodin's String Quartets

Borodin is one of those composers whose body of work is small, but whose best known works have deserved status as repertoire staples for decades. That he managed to write at all remains a point of wonder, given his profession as a chemist, but the concert hall is richer every time the symphonies are performed, the opera house likewise in the case of 'Prince Igor' and the chamber music similarly for each hearing of his two string quartets.

Yet there is a real danger that his music could fall unless it is performed more often. In the 1970s and 1980s the Second Symphony was ubiquitous, but now it barely gets a look-in, and its charming companion the First, full of melodic joie de vivre, gets lesser still exposure.
The second string quartet now enjoys a position right at the top of the list, and if anything is now programmed too much by quartets in Britain. This is understandable, for there are so many richly rewarding melodies within its bars – not least for cellists – but it is a shame that the
First is overlooked at its expense, for this too is a rich mine of attractive music.

The lovely way that the Fitzwilliam Quartet captures the slightly demure opening on this reissue from Eloquence sets the tone, the music blossoming into a more assured first movement. Once the transition is made the musical outlook is a sunny, one, with not much weight applied by the Fitzwilliam at all, until the second theme comes in, the cello digging in a bit to its double stopped accompaniment. The theme is one of Borodin's most attractive, moving with chromatic subtleties in the way he is able to do.

The second movement is nearly as successful, though there is quite an uncomfortable noise at 5'19", with a pretty harsh outburst that sounds stretched, even if it does follow the directed ff dynamic. The quartet redeem this in the Scherzo's trio section with a lovely use of the harmonics in the trio, another great example of Borodin's imaginative writing for stringed instruments. The open textures of the finale’s introduction are nicely done too, appropriately rustic.

The second quartet is very well performed, and the balance keen between the players, an important aspect of this work, is secure. Only the recorded sound can compromise enjoyment, the 25 year old recording benefitting from the remastering process but not fully removing the surface area coarseness. Borodin's humour could perhaps come through here more, in the finale in particular where the stop-start nature is a little business like. The famous Notturno, mind, is ideally judged.

For a relatively modest outlay this is a useful pairing to acquire, especially for the first
Borodin quartet, which is a fine and underrated work indeed. While the Borodin Quartet, named after the composer, remain the last word in interpretations of these wonderful works, the Fitzwilliam slot in close behind.